A Question of Trust Class 10 Notes, Summary & Q&A
1. Introduction to A Question of Trust
Welcome to our comprehensive A Question of Trust Class 10 notes. “A Question of Trust” by Victor Canning (External Link for SEO) is a clever story from the CBSE Class 10 English Footprints Without Feet book. It is based on the famous proverb “Honor among thieves.” The story revolves around Horace Danby, a man who is considered respectable but is secretly a thief. He steals only once a year to fund his expensive hobby of collecting rare books. However, his life takes a sudden turn when he meets a mysterious lady during one of his robberies. Read our full A Question of Trust summary (Internal Link for SEO) below to understand the irony of how a careful professional can be outsmarted.
2. A Question of Trust Characters Sketch
- Horace Danby: A fifty-year-old unmarried man who makes locks. He is generally considered a good and honest citizen, but he robs one safe every year. He loves rare and expensive books and suffers from hay fever.
- The Young Lady in Red: A clever and beautiful thief who pretends to be the mistress of the house at Shotover Grange. She is very manipulative and manages to trick Horace into opening the safe for her.
- Sherry: The pet dog at Shotover Grange whom Horace treats kindly to keep him quiet.
3. A Question of Trust Summary in English
Horace Danby’s Secret Life
Horace Danby was about fifty years old and was a successful locksmith. Everyone thought he was a good, honest man. However, he had a secret: fifteen years ago, he had served time in prison. Now, he robbed one safe every year. He wasn’t a common thief; he stole only from the rich and only to buy rare and expensive books that he loved to collect. He planned each robbery very carefully for months.
Planning at Shotover Grange
For two weeks, Horace had been studying the house at Shotover Grange. He knew exactly where the safe was hidden behind a poor painting in the drawing-room. He knew that the two servants were away at the movies and the owners were in London. He entered the house with his tools, wearing gloves to avoid leaving fingerprints. However, the smell of flowers in the room triggered his hay fever, and he began to sneeze.
The Encounter with the Lady in Red
While he was sneezing, a young, pretty woman dressed in red appeared in the doorway. She spoke to Horace very calmly, as if she were the owner’s wife. She acted as if she had caught a common burglar. Horace was frightened that he would be handed over to the police. The lady told him that she would let him go only if he helped her. She claimed that she had forgotten the numbers to open the safe and needed the jewels for a party that night.
The Big Mistake
Horace, desperate to escape, believed her story completely. In his haste and fear, he took off his gloves and opened the safe for her without thinking. He handed her the jewels and left the house happily, thinking he was safe. He forgot that he had left his fingerprints all over the safe when he removed his gloves.
The Arrest and Irony
Two days later, a policeman arrested Horace for the jewel robbery at Shotover Grange. His fingerprints were found everywhere. The real owner of the house, a sixty-year-old woman with grey hair, said that the story of the young lady was complete nonsense. Horace realized that he had been tricked by another thief. He was sent to prison, where he now works as an assistant librarian. He gets very angry whenever someone mentions “honor among thieves” because he was betrayed by a member of his own profession.
4. A Question of Trust Class 10 MCQs
Q1. Who is the author of “A Question of Trust”?
(a) Ruskin Bond | (b) Victor Canning | (c) Robert Arthur | (d) H.G. Wells
Answer: (b) Victor Canning
Q2. What was Horace Danby’s profession?
(a) Writing | (b) Locksmith | (c) Teaching | (d) Jewelry making
Answer: (b) Locksmith
Q3. Why did Horace Danby rob every year?
(a) To pay his debts | (b) To buy rare and expensive books | (c) To help the poor | (d) He liked stealing
Answer: (b) To buy rare and expensive books
Q4. What disease did Horace Danby suffer from?
(a) Asthma | (b) Hay fever | (c) Diabetes | (d) Fever
Answer: (b) Hay fever
Q5. Where was the safe hidden at Shotover Grange?
(a) Behind a curtain | (b) Inside a cupboard | (c) Behind a poor painting | (d) In the kitchen
Answer: (c) Behind a poor painting
Q6. Who was Sherry?
(a) The owner’s wife | (b) The maid | (c) The pet dog | (d) The young lady
Answer: (c) The pet dog
Q7. What was the color of the dress of the mysterious lady?
(a) Blue | (b) Red | (c) Black | (d) White
Answer: (b) Red
Q8. Why did Horace remove his gloves while opening the safe?
(a) They were dirty | (b) Out of habit | (c) He was nervous and tricked by the lady | (d) The safe was too small
Answer: (c) He was nervous and tricked by the lady
Q9. How many years ago had Horace been in prison?
(a) 10 years | (b) 15 years | (c) 5 years | (d) 20 years
Answer: (b) 15 years
Q10. What is Horace’s job in the prison at the end?
(a) Cook | (b) Locksmith | (c) Assistant librarian | (d) Cleaner
Answer: (c) Assistant librarian
5. A Question of Trust Question Answers (Short)
Q1. Was Horace Danby a typical thief? Why or why not?
Ans. No, Horace was not a typical thief. He was a respected locksmith who stole only once a year. He didn’t steal for greed but to buy expensive and rare books that he loved.
Q2. How did Horace prepare for the robbery at Shotover Grange?
Ans. Horace studied the house for two weeks. He knew the room’s layout, the wiring, the path to the safe, and the movement of the servants. He also knew the pet dog’s name.
Q3. What made Horace sneeze in the drawing-room?
Ans. Horace suffered from hay fever, which is an allergy to pollen. There was a big bowl of flowers in the drawing-room, and their scent triggered his sneezing, which eventually led to his discovery.
Q4. How did the lady in red convince Horace that she was the owner of the house?
Ans. She acted with great confidence and authority. She scolded the dog, moved about the room comfortably, and complained about the burglary. Her calm behavior made Horace believe she belonged there.
Q5. Why was Horace Danby arrested after two days?
Ans. Horace had opened the safe for the lady in red without wearing his gloves. He left his fingerprints everywhere in the room. When the real owner returned, the police used these fingerprints to arrest him.
6. A Question of Trust Important Questions (Long)
Q1. Give a character sketch of Horace Danby.
Ans. Horace Danby was a fifty-year-old locksmith, considered “good and honest” by society. However, he had a secret passion for rare and expensive books, which he funded by robbing one safe every year. He was a meticulous planner and a non-violent man. Despite being a professional, he was naive and easily influenced by fear, which allowed him to be outsmarted by a clever woman. In the end, he represents the irony of a thief being robbed of his trust.
Q2. Describe how the young lady in red managed to outwit the experienced Horace Danby.
Ans. The lady in red used psychology and confidence to outwit Horace. She didn’t act afraid; instead, she acted like the mistress of the house caught in a minor inconvenience. She exploited Horace’s fear of the police by pretending she would let him go if he opened the safe for her. By making him believe he was helping the “owner,” she made him forget his professional caution, leading him to leave fingerprints and get arrested.
Q3. “Honor among thieves” is a major theme in this story. Explain with reference to the plot.
Ans. The proverb “Honor among thieves” suggests that criminals have a code of loyalty toward each other. Horace believed in this idea, which is why he was easily fooled by the lady, thinking a “fellow member of the house” (as she pretended to be) wouldn’t betray him. However, the lady was actually a thief herself who used Horace to do the hard work and then left him to get arrested. This betrayal makes Horace bitter about the concept of honor among criminals.
Q4. What were the mistakes made by Horace Danby that led to his arrest?
Ans. Horace made several fatal mistakes. First, his hay fever made him sneeze, alerting the lady. Second, he was so terrified of the police that he didn’t verify the lady’s identity. Third, and most importantly, he removed his gloves while opening the safe to help the lady. This careless act left his fingerprints on the crime scene. His emotional fear clouded his professional judgment, leading to his downfall.
Q5. Do you think Horace Danby deserved the punishment he got? Give reasons for your answer.
Ans. While Horace was not a violent criminal and stole for the love of books, he was still a thief. Breaking the law is a crime regardless of the motive. However, there is a sense of poetic justice in the story. He was caught not because of a police investigation but because he was outwitted by another thief. His punishment—working in a prison library—is ironic, as he is now surrounded by the very books he once stole to possess.